跳到正文
Rohan Paul· @rohanpaul_ai · X·· 2026-06-27AI 评分75
AI 导读

《华盛顿邮报》报道,基于达特茅斯和斯坦福研究的测试显示,AI聊天机器人在约30项政策议题(税收、医保、移民等)上存在左翼偏见。GPT-5.5仅给出左倾立场占80%,双方立场17%,右倾3%;Gemini 3.1 Pro则93%给出双方立场,左倾仅7%;Claude Opus 4.8双方立场占57%;Grok 4.3是唯一右倾占33%的模型。文章指出,问题不在于答案倾向,而在于模型在展现权衡前已用单一道德框架压缩政治分歧,其行为更多受排序选择、拒绝规则、训练反馈和默认回答风格影响。

正文 · 原文

AI chatbots show left-wing bias, Washington Post report finds, with ChatGPT giving left-leaning answers 80% of time

The test used a structured set of political questions from a Dartmouth and Stanford research study.

The test asked each model about roughly 30 policy issues, including taxes, health care, immigration, guns, affirmative action, and the death penalty.

GPT-5.5 gave only the left-leaning position in 80% of answers, both sides in 17%, and only the right-leaning position in 3%.

Gemini 3.1 Pro looked very different, giving both sides in 93% of answers and left-only answers in 7%.

Claude Opus 4.8 gave both sides in 57%, while Grok 4.3 was the only model with a large right-only share at 33%.

The deeper point is not whether one answer sounds liberal or conservative, but whether a model compresses a political dispute into one moral frame before the user sees the tradeoff.

This test suggests chatbot behavior is shaped less by raw facts than by ranking choices, refusal rules, training feedback, and default answer style.

来源:Rohan Paul · x.com